• Thank you to Carol and Steve Bowman, the forum owners, for our new upgrade!

WWI love and loss

Whippoorwill

Senior Registered
I wanted to share this story with you, it’s still very new and I’m afraid I’m still making sense of it all! Something triggered my memory in October and since then I seem to be remembering things in clearer detail. Where once I only had vague feelings about a couple of lives, now I have a definite impression of the life I lived directly before this one. I've gone into some detail here, about the process of uncovering it all, sorry if it's too much!

Since I was a very small child I’ve had this immense feeling of loss. Of someone being missing. I used to put it down to being an only child, longing for a sibling, but deep down I knew it wasn’t really that. It was an unhappy feeling, but not entirely unpleasant; tempered by the fact that there was such a knowledge of true love behind it all! And I’ll readily admit that it’s like nothing I’ve felt in this lifetime. As I reached the age of about thirteen I started to realize these feelings were for someone who’d left and had never come back. Someone I’d lost in a war. I always assumed it was WWII, because I’ve always loved/worn the clothes and hairstyles from that era.

Anyway, my father has become very interested in genealogy of late, mainly researching his side of the family, so I decided to look into my mother’s side. Her father (who died when I was six) was the youngest of eleven children. She seemed to recall him telling her that he had brothers who had fought in the First World War. I was interested to find them, but had no inkling about any past life. It was just curiosity. I had no idea of their names, but I found a few possible candidates, with the right surname in the right city, but one name in particular had a really strange effect on me. Thomas H. Just to read it gave me a strange sense of joy and sadness, butterflies in my stomach. It was a name I recognized somehow. I checked the address and he was the relative I was looking for. My great uncle, killed in 1916, aged 21.

After asking for confirmation it became clear to me that we’d been sweethearts and I asked where he had died and was told “the Somme”. It seemed an obvious answer and I thought the date would probably prove me wrong. But no, when I managed to find some detailed war records some time later, they said he was killed between the 1st -3rd of July, 1916. The first three days of the Somme. A lucky guess, I thought! I then asked for my name in this life and the word “Clara” popped into my head so clearly, like nothing ever had before. It’s not a name I’d ever given much thought to and I had no idea it was popular in the early 1900s. I couldn’t get a surname, so I smiled to myself, totally unconvinced, thinking that I was probably imagining the whole thing.

Now, the list I’d found him on was actually a forum post detailing local soldiers killed in action, who’d had their photographs published in the newspaper. It gave an exact date for each specific soldier. So, perhaps a week later, I went to the Local Studies Library to hunt down the photograph. It just wasn’t there. The ladies on the desk were incredibly helpful and I remember feeling so incredibly moved that so many people were saying Thomas' name that day. That people were searching for him and caring about him, almost a hundred years after he died. I really could’ve cried. I spent the afternoon in an odd mood. Sad, nostalgic, moved… I just felt like I wasn’t quite there. On the drive home in the car a surname just came to me. I knew it was Clara’s surname. It came to me in such a flash, just like before. When I got home I decided to check the 1911 census out of curiosity, to see if I could find her. I was almost positive that I wouldn’t find a trace of her and that I’d laugh at myself for being so foolish. So I typed her name into the search field and listed her place of residence as “Sheffield” thinking that was perhaps limiting things a little too much, but it was worth a shot. I clicked the search button.

And there she was! Not only living in Sheffield, but living in the small area of Attercliffe, just like Thomas! Only a few streets away from his home, in fact! I went through a range of emotions, stunned, elated, terrified. I think if I’d simply thought of the name and found it I wouldn’t have been so taken aback, but for the story to tie in so well to the feelings of loss that I’d experienced throughout my entire life, well, that was really something extraordinary. And banking on the fact that she never married, there was a Clara in the same city, born in the same month and year, who died in 1979. Three years before I was born. It all just fitted so well.

I think one of the first feelings to hit me, oddly enough, was “I’ve lost his letters!” It was a sick feeling of panic, as if I’d left the house wearing a precious necklace, only to find that it was no longer around my neck when I returned home. I just didn’t know what to do with myself, I was frantic. It was as though I’d lost him all over again; no letters, no mementos, nothing to hold on to! It was a horrible feeling and gave way to this awful sense of grief, somehow distant, but definitely mine. I started trawling eBay for WWI letters, hoping to find my name or his. I searched for regiment badges and buttons and medals. I felt like I had to replace the belongings I’d clung to during my previous life. It was madness.

I wondered why he wasn’t with me in this current life and was told that due to the trauma of his death, he wasn’t ready to reincarnate at the point that I was. His sudden death, combined with the anguish of having killed meant he needed extra time to heal and to reflect on his previous life. Instead he had chosen to support me as one of my guides.

So, it was all fitting into place and seeming so much more real. The only thing nagging at me was the age difference between Thomas and Clara. I suppose four years is perfectly acceptable, but when I checked Thomas’ sign-up papers I realized that he’d joined the army in 1915, at the age of nineteen, making Clara only fifteen. I wasn’t sure if this was an acceptable age difference, or if Clara would be considered old enough to begin a relationship, let alone with a man considered adult enough to go to war! It was really frustrating to have found such compelling evidence, only for everything to be undermined by such an insignificant thing as an age-gap! I scoured the internet for information on Edwardian dating etiquette, but I found nothing. In my desperation I wrote an email to an author I’d found online, who penned WWI romances and ran a website on Edwardian etiquette. I decided to be honest and tell her exactly why I was asking, assuming she’d think me mad and never reply. But she did. She very kindly told me that it would have been perfectly normal. Once a girl was old enough to leave school, she was considered old enough to court and think about marriage. Clara and Thomas were both from very poor backgrounds, with most children starting work at the age of twelve.

Since then I’ve tried to remember some details. The most interesting thing I saw was a grimy postcard. It was old, antique. I could see the cursive script on it, in thick-ish black ink. The only word I could read was Clara, although I believe it was addressed to someone else. But all my focus was being drawn to that name, halfway down the text. The strange thing was that the handwriting was much messier and looser than the example I’d seen on his sign-up papers, which was extraordinarily neat. I put it down to writing quickly, in less-than-ideal conditions, but was still a little thrown and disappointed by it. But then, a few days later, I found out that the sign-up papers I’d obtained were incorrect and belonged to someone else with the same name! When I compared the handwriting on Thomas’ actual papers, it was much more like the writing in my vision!

I’ve tried various techniques and seen a few glimpses of that life, but I’m so imaginative I can’t disregard the fact that I might just be romanticising! I seem to recall being at the dining table when I got the news that he’d been killed. A visit from his sister, perhaps. I can see the wallpaper and the large mirror hanging on the wall, the shine on the wood of the table, on the gaps between a crocheted tablecloth, all in perfect detail, the way your memory somehow takes a picture during a traumatic event. Flashbulb memory.

My impressions of the rest of Clara’s life are vague. The odd thing is that she’d have been living in the same part of the city as my mum, for over thirty years! I feel she never married and was looked after by her brother. I get the impression that she was very lonely, never entering into another relationship for fear of betraying Thomas. I’ve always had this strange fascination with my mum’s maiden name, desperately wishing it were mine and to this day I have an inexplicable fear of putting a ring on my left ring finger, I just can’t do it, can’t even try one on! I feel enormous guilt at being in relationships and can never settle. I’m still living at home because I can’t bring myself to move in with anyone, let alone marry! I also have a constant fear of bad news, every time the phone rings I panic, sure that someone has died (although I know Clara wouldn’t have had a phone, it’s just the way we convey news now!)

I just can’t imagine why I’d choose to live yet another life without him! I remember reading about Peter Cushing’s grief after losing his wife, Helen. He said that his life was spent simply waiting to be with her again, he was just wasting time. And that’s how I feel, to some extent. Perhaps regression might help me find my path, I'm sure there must be one. At present I’m just left with this overwhelming urge to know what it was like in the trenches, what he went through over there and exactly how he died (knowledge that was obviously unavailable and glossed over at the time!). I’ve been reading books about the Somme and trying to find out about his battalion. There’s a part of me that wants to know everything and part that can’t bear to hear it. It’s a very odd feeling.

Anyway, thanks for reading, I’m embarrassed that this was so lengthy!
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Thanks for sharing that Whipoorwill, it was fascinating to read, and very moving, I can feel your emotion coming through the words in your post.


I'm not very good at offering words of comfort or advice, but I can certainly relate to your feelings to a certain extent. You obviously have a strong bond with the soul who once lived as Thomas H. I know it's not much compensation right now to hear me say that you will be together again, either in this life or future lives to come. I believe that soul partners, separated in life, are never really apart beyond the physical realm. Perhaps some regression therapy can help you to view matters from a different perspective and maybe accept your situation a bit better? We are always here to listen and support you of course, but I think you need more than that?


Have you been to Attercliffe in your current life? I don't know if it would make you feel better or worse. There's a good website called vpike, it's a bit like Street View, where you can virtually walk the streets of almost any chosen location. You never know, you might recognize some of the scenery if you visit the site and explore Attercliffe.
 
Thank you for posting this. Not very often do we hear WWI stories. If you haven't already you need to read Carol's book called "Return From Heaven". It's about same family reincarnation. It appears to be much more common than anyone thought. There is also a website called www.newspaperarchive.com that has digitized thousands of microfilm newspapers worldwide. They are much easier to read than on the microfilm reader in the library and they are "searchable".
 
That was so moving, Whipoorwill, thanks for sharing.


I have a very similar past life during WWII, but I am still very far from validating anything, I don't seem to get enough details or names to do a proper research, but undoubtedly you have given me new strength to keep on searching.


I also lost him in the war, and very short after his death I decided I couldn't live anymore. I also think he's my guide now, I also missed someone my entire life, since I was just a kid, and I found out all this when I started to meditate last year. He's been with me in other lifetimes, and though I know he's always near it's still hard sometimes to be apart, I still miss him so much...


So you can be sure I completely understand your feelings. Again, thank you very much.
 
ChrisR Thank you so much for your kind reply, it meant so much. I think I probably painted a blacker picture than I intended :) . As you say, I do truly believe we'll be together again (as we have been before)! I have a good life, just with very little direction at present. But yes, I'm definitely aiming for regression, just holding out for the right person to help me!


You know, that's a very interesting question and one I've been thinking about a lot over the past few months. I actually still live nearby, perhaps 30 minutes from Attercliffe. Unfortunately it doesn't really exist anymore, most of it was leveled to make way for a large shopping center. The houses are all gone, but of course the roads are still there. I've driven along the outskirts on my way to the shops, but it's not the same as exploring on foot! My mother was born there and says we'll have to take a trip. She knows about the name I found on the census, but not much else, I felt uncomfortable discussing it with her, which is a shame, we can usually talk about anything!


I'm very torn. On one hand I'd love to visit and see if anything seems familiar or if I can trigger a memory, but I don't want to deprive myself of any evidence. I'm so desperate for more proof that if I could just remember a bend in the road, or a building that still exists and sketch it before I visited, then I'd feel more secure! It's so frustrating, I wish I could just trust myself.


argonne1918 Thanks so much for the info. I've been reading your posts in the forum and it's so good to speak to you, knowing we were of the same generation. It's oddly comforting. I will check out the website you mentioned. I work in a library and am lucky enough to freely search some databases, but they tend to be rather limited, so I shall look forward to searching this one!


Eowyn No, I should be thanking you! I can't begin to tell you what your reply meant to me! Honestly, it's such a relief to find someone with a similar story. I was exactly the same, I didn't have any details until last October, just the very real feelings of loss. I'm so sorry that you had to go through the same thing. I know exactly what you mean, having him with me is a such a comfort, and more so as time goes on. I was really uncomfortable about the idea of having a guide, and at first it was just thoughts that could be my own, but now I feel as though he's truly with me at times. I visited the war memorial in the village where I live and placed my poppy there, in memory of him. When I made time to speak to him that evening I could feel him almost bouncing up and down, so joyous that I'd made that gesture for him.


I think your gentleman must be so pleased to be recognised and to know that you can hear him. So many guides must be resigned to never being acknowledged.


If ever you want to talk or share ideas send me a PM and we can compare our experiences. :)
 
Whippoorwill, your story is very beautiful. The strength of your memories, coupled with the confirmation from your research, must have been overpowering. I think there has to be a reason that all this information came flooding back. I think ChrisR is right, and you need help from someone who specializes in regression therapy to put everything in perspective. My feelings about your story range from amazement, to bewilderment, to envy! In all my reading, I've never come across anything quite like it. Are you sure Thomas is functioning as your spirit guide, and is not experiencing confusion as to his role in your life? I have been told that people who love us are not necessarily wiser than when they existed on this plane. He was a very young man when he passed. I think the bond between you must be incredibly powerful. Someday, when you understand all the nuances of this experience, it would make an incredible book, whether you write it as a guide to help others, or as Taylor Caldwell did, as a novel.
 
Thank you for sharing, it was beautiful to read. Perhaps he is revealing himself to you now so that you can have the closure you need to fall in love in this lifetime?


Falling in love now would not be cheating on his memory, this is a new life, a new time.


I am glad you have been able to speak to him, and he has been so helpful to you. Have you tried asking if the postcard still exists, and if so, if he knows where it ... or anything of his ... is?
 
Whippoorwill, thank you so much for sharing your story. It has really touched many of us, including myself. I couldnt stop thinking about it all yesterday; it was touching to hear a story of the Great War from the perspective of those left behind. I also suffered loss in the Great War; I survived, whereas so many others didn't, which left me with a lot of guilt which I have only recently been able to address. Standing at a war memorial in this life brought back the strong impression that Id done the same many years ago, as one of the few to return.


You have such a gift, to have been able to verify so much, much more than many of us! The joy your Thomas must have felt at your visit to the war memorial must have been wonderful to experience! You are so lucky to have so much information you can verify too, I dont even have a full name yet, just vague impressions and snippets of things that cant yet be verified from any records.


Please keep us updated with your journey of discovery. Its been amazing reading your posts so far!
 
BriarRose Thank you. Yes, finding proof was pretty overwhelming and not something I'd ever expected. It all just happened so quickly too, within weeks really.


You know, I agree completely. I suppose "guide" is ultimately my word, not his, and not one I'm entirely comfortable with. It's not a subject I'm well versed in, although I've been reading as much as I can lately. The best way I can describe it is as a feeling that he's an "honorary" guide, there to build self-faith and to offer comfort, support and companionship whilst I start to understand my own spirituality.


I've never really been aware of other guides, I'm just so skeptical about it all! And perhaps that's why he's important, because we do have a powerful link and he can get through, despite my doubts? It always feels like he's surprised he's been allowed to do this. Haha! He does feel young and a little giddy. I feel like he wants to share this life with me and "not get left behind" in terms of culture and technology after nearly a hundred years without incarnating. I know that sounds silly, but it's the impression I'm getting from him. As I said, I find it quite tiring to communicate, with regard to sending out my own thoughts, rather than receiving them (which is one of the things that goes a little way to lessen my doubts). I feel like he's always there, eager to chat to me, excited that he can finally get through and I have to apologise and refuse him a lot of the time.


I should probably explain what I meant when I mentioned him saying he was "as good a guide as he was a soldier" - I've had terrible trouble with empathy over the past few years, I can't seem to successfully shut people out. I work with the public and I seem to take on all their unhappiness. I only have to see a small cut on someone's hand and it stays with me all day. Guilt, fear, sorrow. It was regarding this that he apologised. I think he wishes he could be a help to me in other aspects, but that's not his role. Does that make sense?


One day I'll trust myself about this and the next I'll think it's wish fulfillment and my own imagination replying to me! But then he'll mischievously give me the answer to a question on a quiz show, that makes my family gape at me in amazement! I joke about having a spirit guide to my dad and that's the one thing that's got him wondering! Sometimes I'll ask for help locating books at work and I instantly find them if I trust him to direct me. So, in conclusion, I think his role is a lighthearted, lesser support role, rather than a main guide.


I'm glad you and ChrisR agree that regression would be the right step for me. The work I've done with meditation and self-hypnosis is extremely minimal, so that's the first step, I think. I'm just waiting for the right hypnotherapist or psychic to come along. I've been looking at the brilliant resources on this site, but most of the professionals are quite a distance from where I live and I don't drive. I want to be sure that the person I choose is a believer and not someone simply offering the service alongside therapy for dieting, smoking and anxiety.


Mama2HRB Thank you! I'm so glad you read my story and enjoyed it, I was worried I'd gone into a little too much detail! I'd never make a good editor!


You might well be right! What a lovely thought :) . I have a wonderful, supportive partner of seven years and have had previous relationships, but things just never match up to the feelings I've had since childhood. I know most people would say I'm just being idealistic and every little girl longs for her Prince Charming, but it's always been deeper than that, like I've known what true love is and exactly how it feels, but never experienced it. Despite this, as I said, I think my partner played the role of my brother in our last life together. So I love him dearly, it's just a little more platonic (on my side) than I'd like!


I've heard some people say that entire lives are drawn up before we are born, with everything happening for a reason, but my own belief is that fate and freewill will often disrupt these plans. And so the soul I was supposed to spend my last life with was taken away and my plans were never fulfilled, a feeling which has carried over into this one. Therein lies my problem, I think! Perhaps a little more work may help me overcome this.


If he knows about the postcard, he isn't telling me! Only that it's out there. With my grandfather having such a large family, anyone could have inherited these things (I'd love to see his medals!). I think I need to try and track them down. Imagine if I found the postcard! Or anything at all mentioning Clara, I think it would be the ultimate proof I needed to truly believe in all this. I might try asking in the forum where this all started, the one with the list of soldiers. They all seem to be big family history buffs, so I'll casually drop in a few names and see if anyone recognises them from their family tree!
 
helz_belz Thank you so much for your reply, it's so wonderful to hear from someone who lived at the same time, but I'm so sorry your life was also so touched by the war. I can't imagine what it must have felt like to return, knowing so many had been lost. And I'm sure a large part of yourself was missing also. I feel so lucky that my memories are of home life, I can't begin to imagine what you must have suffered. I do have very vague memories of battlefields, but from earlier times. It's just a feeling really, if I'm walking in the fields and see a certain type of landscape I'm just struck with this awful fear and dizziness and the feeling I'm going to be sick.


It's odd that you should mention standing by the war memorial, I had the same experience. For me it's a mixture of loss and comfort, as if it was a place I'd visited often, like a graveside. I can't seem to track down the war memorial his name would have been on, it would have been interesting to visit it. I think it may have been destroyed in WWII, or during more recent work to that part of the city. If it has been destroyed or removed, I'm all set to start a petition for a replacement! The council will feel my wrath! To be honest I'd forgotten about the poppy when I tried to speak to him that night and just got this whooping sense of excitement, like butterflies. I suppose to him, he'd got his Clara back in that moment. A connection to the past somehow. I'm always painfully aware that it's probably my own imagination replying to me, but at times like that I do wonder! :)


Yes, it's been a wonderful experience to have been given proof and I feel guilty that I'm not even more convinced by it. Finding the name on the census was truly something I can't put into words, but it all happened so quickly! From lifelong feelings to having a name, I just wish I'd had some memories in between! I worry that the ones I've managed to uncover now are as a direct result of the information I have. If I could just positively link Clara to Thomas somehow, I think that would truly convince me that I'm not being fanciful! As I said, it's just unfortunate that the life that I know the most about seems so romantic! If I was getting more details about my life during the English Civil War, I think I'd be more convinced somehow!


I'd love to hear your story, I'll have to track down your posts! It's really comforting to speak to someone who was there, as silly as that sounds.
 
It's such a pleasure to read your words, Whipoorwill, I'll certainly PM you soon, I am not feeling too right lately due to this past life I mentioned, but hearing you has cheered me up.
 
Eowyn I can understand completely. I was really struggling with this until very recently and even now I have unhappy days thinking about it. I'm so sorry you're having a difficult time. Try to find joy in the love you felt and if you need anything at all, I'm more than willing to listen. hug2.gif
 
Hi Whippoorwill, I identify with so many of the things you are writing about. I think quite a few people on this forum tend to be empathic, including myself. I can't look at another person's cut, I feel the same thing. My PL process has been like yours. I got names, then did the research. I don't think I had direct memories of my two most immediate past lives. When I found the records, everything "fit". I find it hard to trust what I have found, being an imaginative person. I really like Mama2HRB's idea of the purpose of your memories. She's always the voice of common sense! Is it possible that Thomas can help you contact your other spirit guides? I think for you, it would be very helpful if you could remember a few lives other than the one with Thomas. Perspective would come. Perhaps if you contacted Carol Bowman, she could refer you to a person in the U.K. who is qualified to do regression therapy. I look forward to hearing the next "chapter" in your story.
 
Whippoorwill said:
I'm just waiting for the right hypnotherapist or psychic to come along. I've been looking at the brilliant resources on this site, but most of the professionals are quite a distance from where I live and I don't drive.
There's a directory of UK based past life regression therapists here. They are all qualified, and members of the Past Life Therapists Association. There are 3 in your county, not too far away from you I hope.
 
Amazing...Thank you for posting this! A fascinating real-life story to read - the turn of events that led you down your path of research...The fact that you found Clara on that Census, that is such a validation!


I hope you keep in touch and become a regular here! :)
 
Hello Whippoorwill. There is always something affirming about finding and talking to others who were around at the same time as ourselves. Talking about these things with like-minded people here on the forum really does help to start to make sense of everything we are feeling and experiencing :)


At present I don’t have any direct memories of the trenches, just vague feelings about the Western Front. As to whether I’ve deliberately forgotten, or wasn’t in the trenches (much war work occurred far from the Front), I’m not sure. These things will come to me as and when I’m ready I suppose, maybe I’m just not ready to remember the horrors.


War memorials are very powerful places, so much emotion has been poured into them. I hope you can find what happened to Thomas’ war memorial. Councils do some crazy things, but knocking down war memorials can’t be one of them (I hope!). Have you tried looking at the UK War Memorials Archive? http://www.ukniwm.org.uk/ you might be able to find some info on there. The War Memorials Trust might be useful too: http://www.warmemorials.org/links-england/


Don’t worry if you think you’re going crazy/have an overactive imagination, I feel the same way much of the time too! Can’t help but think I’m just making this all up! Am trying not to read up or research too much in case it ‘contaminates’ my memories in some way ;)
 
BriarRose - I agree completely with you about looking into other lives. I've been concentrating on the two other vague memories I have: English Civil War parliamentarian circa 1647 and Scottish camp follower from an unknown era, 1000AD ish.


Glad to hear I'm not alone with the empathy problems! Though I'm sorry that you suffer too!


ChrisR Thanks so much! Oddly enough there's one in the nearest city to me (and where the past life I've mentioned took place!). Not only that, but she's someone I had a good feeling about when I visited her website late last year! Brilliant news.


Lady2 I can't tell you how much faith it gives me to hear you say that about my story. There are times when I think "oh, it's just a coincidence that I came up with that name!" but when other people think it's a great validation, I find that such a confidence boost. Thank you. Oh, I definitely plan to stick around! I can honestly say that I've never found such a lovely group of people online. Truly.


helz_belz Thank you so much for the links, I'll see if I can find anything. I've been on some local history forums and no one seems to know what happened to it. How sad! I'm so glad you feel the same regarding research, I'm so torn! I want it to trigger something and yet not contaminate anything. I suppose I'll have to find a happy medium.
 
Back
Top